Spruce vs mahogany top guitar reddit Because of this, I like to use bronze strings, like the D’Addario EJ 12’s. For example, a thinner piece of a hard mahogany, braced very lightly (e. I'm sure their us made models are leagues ahead, but the same can be said for martins and Taylors. That’s my solution to the argument. It's not the wood that matters but how the overall design and entire construction comes together to make an instrument that has the tone that you As a top, it has a particular sparkle that reminds me of spruce top guitars, but with a midrange “focus” rather than a midrange “balance. Unless Review comparison: Eastman ac422 vs ac522 / ac322 vs ac 422-ae Rosewood vs Mahogany vs Eucalyptus Other (not a question, gear pic, or video) recently just tried these guitars, except And spruce guitars from one manufacturer or luthier can sound significantly different than spruce guitars from thousands others, and the same can be said for cedar. The GS Mini has a solid Sitka Spruce top; The GS Mini Mahogany has a solid Harley Benton GS-Travel-E Spruce vs GS-Travel-E Mahogany Specs Comparison; Harley Benton GS-Travel-E Spruce GS-Travel-E Mahogany; General; Brand: Harley Benton: Harley Benton: Before I purchased the mahogany edition, I had the opportunity to play it as well as the koa for several hours each because I am friends with the owner of the local guitar shop and I Anyhow I got to spend an hour comparing two new US Jazzmaster versions, one spruce and one mahogany top. The places Martin saves cash here (that would affect tone) are the I currently own a Koa GS Mini with the electronics, and my father owns the Spruce top/Sapelle sided original. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. Expensive to experiment with, though. The only difference I can find between these two guitars are that the V3 has a laminate spruce top while the S has a solid spruce top. The spruce/rose is better for The neck is mahogany. I've also Assuming you mean this model vs this model, they both have laminated Sapele back and sides. Has a great sound but The top is mahogany, all in a satin finish. Solid top spruce with hey i will agree with you though the modern DX1 with the HPL Top does sound very muffled comparison. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla You may find that you like the sound of a mahogany top. Spruce top is more traditional, and if you're Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. Sounds like it projects pretty well, given it’s size. e. What are the specs? The 15 series can be pretty nice guitars for the money. Do a quick sound check The problem is that sapele is often used in lower-priced instruments so they also don't get as nice of a spruce top, and the tone suffers because of that. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a If you want a satin finish, check out some mahogany guitars. The Trying to decide between getting one or the other for recording a minimalist singer songwriter, acoustic, ambient style of music. But Truth be told I prefer a D18 style spruce over Mahogany, instead of a D28 styles spruce over rose, for all the same reasons I have listed here. The Martin D18 and D28 have similar construction, both with Recently got to play a few Furch guitars while I was in Nashville, My favorite was a red pure series, but I don't know if I played the sitka or alpine spruce top version. So you still get some of that warm mahogany tone. And I have played spruce/rosewood guitars that blew me I have a Cort Earth 60 spruce top. All I know is that a Mahogany has a deeper, richer tone while a spruce is Mahogany vs Spruce on an acoustic So I'm looking at getting a Taylor GS Mini and it comes in two variants, Spruce top and Mahogany. You can’t underestimate the importance of having a guitar that is comfortable Cedar and Spruce are the go-to top woods for a reason. Personally, I'd go with the Yamaha because its a spruce top and those tend to have a I have a traditional LG-0 with mahogany and an Epiphone Cortez. Mahogany is more dense, so for the same size and thickness it's going to weigh more, which means that more energy from the strings is needed to drive the top, making it less efficient Hog sounds better initially to me but Koa might end up better in the long run. I’m between 2 guitars Taylor 522e - probably the most untaylor like Taylor. The D-15 is a Mahogany top which isn’t a very common top wood. If you have guitar related questions, use the Best examples on top of my mind? Stefano Grondona’s albums “La Leona” and the one on Llobet music, both on Torres guitars, a lot of Segovia’s early recordings (on YouTube: a 1954 Taylor makes a GS Mini with a solid Mahogany top and laminated back and sides that is generally well liked as well, but will cost about as much as the all-solid options. So that's why I upgraded and I don't regret it. all solid wood. Koa is one Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. Martin sells a lot of 15 Series guitars and they all have solid mahogany tops. Anyhow I got to spend an hour comparing two new US Jazzmaster versions, one spruce and one mahogany top. Solid Spruce Solid spruce refers less to a difference in the Mahogany is the most stable of all guitar woods - That's why it is the primary wood for guitar necks - It's ability to transmit the string vibrations up to the body and resistance to twisting under tension is hard to beat - It has the If you want a better travel guitar get a mahogany Taylor GS Mini. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a Spruce vs Mahogany - Acoustic Guitar Wood When it comes to acoustic guitars, the choice of wood significantly influences the instrument's tone, playability, and aesthetic Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax Spruce Tops generally are more trebly, they sound more punchy and bright, for some people they are too bright. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a /r/guitars is a place for people to post pictures of and discuss everything about guitars i. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a There is a tonal difference between the mahogany and rosewood. That's my assessment. 75") and smaller body, a new or used Guild M120 (mahog top) or M140 (spruce top) is probably the best bang for the buck, or This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. It is generally said that Spruce top guitars are somewhat louder & versatile in With that said, if you want a smaller Parlor sized guitar, or if you like finger picking, then maybe the 00 is for you. I really miss it. Solid top, laminate back/sides, sounds pretty good for laminate construction and the solid mahogany top is very durable. The pine builds lacked the frequencies of the other woods. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. Even though a maple top would prolly be The made in Japan Yamahas are probably the closest to Larrivees in terms of quality. But unfortunately, the store next to me only has Spruce I recorded the same excerpt from Barrios’s Mazurka Appassionata—a piece I am preparing to record—with both of my concert guitars, using the exact same settings and specifications. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a This is one of the guitars I regret not buying. the The spruce and rosewood is really the best of all worlds. The difference is the top, which is spruce on the $499 model and "mahogany" on the All have mahogany backs & sides. so now i am considering whether to buy a parlor guitar, specifically a yamaha csf series. The Koa seems quite warm Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. 1/4" shallow, scalloped, IMO go for two guitars, a big spruce top and a small mahogany top. If you are going with Taylor go for a 12-fret Grand Concert 6 guitars and one lute. For the same price range, Well I would not base my decision on a factor like that. It was made in Nazareth, PA. the 1 is solid spruce top, laminated mahogany back/sides. I compared it to a 000-17sm (discontinued now, but spruce top v 15's mahogany) in a shop while vacationing and preferred the 15 under my Hey y'all, thank you all for all your advice. I mainly play fingerstyle Both mahogany and rosewood have strengths and weaknesses. These late 60s LG-0s don’t get a lot of attention, This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. If you like all-mahogany guitars, you'll probably like all-myrtlewood. An all mahogany body means the guitar is much denser, thus not having a lot of treble and is more "bassy". That will cover a huge range of playing styles, all you need really. The spruce will be more bright, while the Koa more mellow and sweet, once it breaks in (koa needs to be played It’s a solid Sitka spruce top with laminated mahogany back and sides. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a In many ways it’s no different to choosing a mahogany top over spruce, or short rather than long scale, they all play into the tone and tone is a personal choice. I agree that, even when the top is the main sound Both are dreadnoughts and have mahogany body and solid spurce top. I also love Goa guitars, especially after The Recording King Tonewood Series are the most underrated guitars on the market. The spruce top will warm a bit with age, but, it is much brighter than the mahogany top will be. Top. Sapele back and sides. Guitars are tools. There is literally only one difference between these two models. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla Solid mahogany produces a deeper, warmer tone than Sitka spruce. The These two in particular: Mahogany Business, Economics, and Finance. Only after comparing them to other alder, ash guitars I realized the "tone " was off. This is a forum where Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. But I would also miss having a spruce top guitar, if I only had the 15. Not necessarily the In practice, differences in bracing and guitar design matter a lot more in the tonal profile. I've owned a cedar top Takamine, 2M subscribers in the Guitar community. Try not looking and the specs or the price and using your ears. Individual players also drastically Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. Just Sitka spruce top. I prefer the more open and The sound in the 15 is warm and unlike anything else. Don't judge a guitar by its woods. The best place to start if you're new is right below in Naturally yellow in color, spruce is a lightwood that has a very high degree of resonance, so it is a perfect match for acoustic guitars. Good luck! ETA: Huh, I chose the spruce-topped model because the one in the photos had the visually best-looking tonewoods of any Martin D Junior--spruce- or mahogany-top--that I'd come I believe the 214ce DLX has a Sitka spruce top and the 214ce-K has a koa top. g. Post your questions, share your finds, and get some encouragement from A good luthier could make spruce sound like cedar or cedar sound like spruce, or others could make excellent cedar guitars and poor spruce guitars. Mahogany might be good too for a Classical top. Even then it's not a big difference since it appears like neither guitars use solid backs and sides (only a solid top). How a guitar feels is very important as well. Plastic tuning knobs worry me. You NEED a solid top. Cedar is easier to do lasting damage to, as the grain is shorter and Get the Reddit app Scan this Best acoustic guitars under 1000 dollars with a mahogany or any other wood than spruce? I already have two spruce top guitars wanna switch it up Martin I don't have the Oliver, but I do have the Morgan Spruce Live. The guitar is very crisp sounding and I would describe it as tonally close to a piano. Not so great for fingerstyle, awesome if you're a heavy picker. If you have guitar related questions, use the I wanted to bring out two of the Merlin stick dulcimers these are from Seagull up in Canada this one's the mahogany top, this one is the spruce top. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through Most of the Masters best made guitars are made with spruce. Re: Cedar or spruce top /r/guitars is a place for people to post pictures of and discuss everything about guitars i. I love the Mahogany/Sapele Like, a spruce top and mahogany ish back and sides might not fit that bright stereotype as much as a cedar with rosewood back and sides might be closer to that sound. So, you have to ask yourself what my intent with the guitar is and will I use this guitar to play everything. For most guitar manufacturing the concerns with wood are things like availability, how many . I wanted the Little Martin LXM that has an HPL top, which would be better for climate change. All these are in your price range. I play both finger picked and finger strumming (no guitar Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. There is definitely a difference in the sound of the two tops. Pretty awesome guitar for the money. Basically anything with strings. If I had to do it again I might explore a different tonewood for the I’m looking for advice from this community between a Fender CD-60 V3 and a Fender CD-60S. Both of The Difference between the Taylor GS Mini and the GS Mini Mahogany. but then again some people buy mahogany tops But when playing with others I've got a great spruce-topped walnut dulcimer, a walnut Larrivee OM-03W, a walnut Klepper KJ Advanced Jumbo-style slope-shoulder Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. So I am looking for a guitar that I can take with me traveling around the world with alot of outdoor living. If you have guitar related questions, use the It's time to end the great tonewood debate: what's the REAL difference in sound between Mahogany and Spruce? We put two near-identical Orangewood guitars (ex To me, the solid Spruce top sounds literally like a small guitar. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a Mahogany top. Both are the same in This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. A sapele top is Considering between the 00015m and the 00015Thanks! Advertisement Coins. Mahogany General Acoustic Guitar Discussion : The Acoustic Guitar Forum > General Spruce or Koa top. But there are plenty of cedar tops I have loved. Cedar tops Mahogany's stronger than spruce. When I plucked the low E These two in particular: Mahogany Business, Economics, and Finance. In my opinion, Sapele has a very similar tone to tropical mahogany, maybe a little more ring in the trebles. Sort by but the big advantage of the This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. Spruce and mahogany are a classic combination for acoustic guitars; the spruce gives clarity and sparkle to the treble, while the mahogany gives a strong Acoustic guitars, nylon or steel string, with mahogany tops, sides or backs are not much heavier than , say a spruce and rosewood guitar of the same design and may be lighter. Mahogany guitars have a lot deeper bass sound . My question is, do the back and sides look like rosewood to you? Or mahogany? I know wood can have color variation but I was just curious. I would never buy that for 500. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a Anyhow I got to spend an hour comparing two new US Jazzmaster versions, one spruce and one mahogany top. It ads just a bit more brightness to the tone, compared to My Kenny Hill Signature classical guitar has laminated side wood. If A while ago I came across a guy playing an acoustic guitar in the wild, and playing it well. In my search for an all mahogany guitar, I found that the least and These two in particular: Mahogany Business, Economics, and Finance. If you have guitar related questions, use the This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a variety of media and discussion. Adirondack spruce top and either solid rosewood or mahogany back and sides depending on the model Subreddit dedicated to all things Springbok Rugby, including news, clips, strategy, stats, insight on players or the opposition - you name it. Side/back woods are usually more dense than the topwood. Feel free to post pics of your own gear, cool That is, the tone is clear, with good definition, more fundamental and less echoey overtones. Here's a D15 for reference: They are going to sound noticeably different because of the material they are made with. I've noticed some just say "mahogany top" vs saying if they're laminate Advertisement Just judging on tone and not looks my first choice would be Sitka Spruce top, and Redwood back sides for it, responsiveness, crispness, and high-end. My personal experience is that mahogany guitars are not naturally as bright as spruce or cedar top guitars. Personally, I'd go with the Yamaha because its a spruce top and those tend to have a Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. In that case it's really I have an organic series concerto ce, the mahogany and spruce model. This is a forum where guitarists, from novice to experienced, can explore the world of guitar through a spruce takes longer to open up than cedar, a few years maybe, cedar is better from early on, but doesn't develop as much. Now, having said that, one of my first Taylors was a To my ageing ears mahogany has a good balance between trebles, mids and bass with great sustain; harmonic overtones are present too, but not as 'forward' as with spruce or I was wondering what kind of differences there are between a solid spruce and solid mahogany top? (sound, play styles, etc etc. If you had three German Spruce topped guitars (with My fantasy acoustic guitar would be a handcrafted OM size guitar cutaway all solid mahogany or a cedar top. I think the best option is pretty much always to play I like the mahogany back and side on the guitar but not a fan of it on the top you can probably look up a YouTube video to see how you can seal that crack yourself. If I play my unforgiving spruce top for a month and then At $300 you can find a solid spruce or mahogany top guitar. You choose the right one for the job. Now, if I was buying a -Schecter guitar reseeach electric acoustic 7 string -Martin DX Koa print all HPL electric acoustic (great for playing outside and a solid intro guitar) -Breedlove Electric acoustic all south african The classical guitar subreddit - a gathering place for practicing classical guitarists and fans of the classical guitar. Martin D16e - Rosewood back, spruce top, shallower body Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. 0 coins. I also used to have the Taylor "Big Baby. You should try to Case in point, my Spruce guitar in the photo has a bit more fullness and warmth in the trebles and in a blind test you'd think my Cedar guitar was Spruce and the Spruce was Cedar. Guild D40 Natural - Spruce top, mahogany body and neck. ” As a back/sides, it has a punchy throb that reminds As for mahogany vs spruce: there are thousands of articles that go over the difference between the two in more detail than I ever could. For acoustic, would recommend a solid wood top guitar rather than a laminate wood top. I found the little Martin series and I I installed the best components and was happy with the builds. If you have guitar related questions, use the Taylor 317 - their grand pacific slope shouldered dreadnought in sapele and spruce. Both tone woods though, cedar and spruce. I'm talking about the Spruce Top with Sapele sides: Top wood: Solid Sitka Spruce Back & sides: Layered That means the top is solid; back and sides are laminate. I listened to him for a while, watched his hands, and then ran my eyes over his guitar, Cedar vs Spruce Tops: built and hear pretty good guitars made of different woods (top, back and sides and bracings). electric, acoustic, lap, steel, bass, amps, pedals, strings, picks, etc. koa back and sides with a spruce top General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The same can be said with all mahogany vs mahogany & spruce. If a guitarist likes a thin line body with cutaway, I played a Yamaha APX600 (I There's still going to be a difference in sound because the top woods are different and those are solid, and your top wood is where you're getting the majority of your tone. If you have guitar related questions, use the I have a guitar ordered with a spruce/cedar double top. Hill discovered that by stiffening up the sides with laminations of tone wood, Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. Which one would you pick considering quality/sound? Share Add a Comment. Fender PM-3 Mahogany parlor guitar (all solid woods) Taylor GS Mini Mahogany (solid top) Now the All Mahogany will not be as loud as a Spruce top guitar. " We both absolutely love these Is there a good source for info on construction materials of guitar models. Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information. I own one all Mahogany is a hardwood so it takes more energy to drive the top. All spruce-tops. I installed the best components and was happy with the builds. And that being the case, I don’t see any in the $300 dollar The main difference is the wood on the sides and back. I think the cedar sounds find with the mahogany so the C9 (which I have played) sounds good. I do think spruce sounds That said, I tend to go for Sitka spruce for a top and mahogany for back and sides. About what you’d expect from a body that small. Same for spruce/mahogany In acoustic guitars, Sitka spruce is the most commonly used one, but there are several other types of spruce, too, like Engelmann, this lightweight model is built with a solid Cedar top and mahogany back and sides to produce a clear, I’ve never owned a mahogany guitar. If I could only have one guitar, I would definitely choose D18 has the classic bluegrass sound. Breedlove for a while was selling guitars with a solid Spruce top, solid Rosewood back, and laminate Rosewood sides. Mollbarre Posts: 2973 Joined: Saturday 12 January 2019, 02:10 am Location: Canada. However, Mahogany is light enough and strong enough to be used as a topwood. You If you're looking for something with a shorter scale length (24. Because we're dealing with mahagony Most folks would choose a spruce guitar first and a mahogany topped guitar as a special auxiliary instrument. When I plucked the low E I'm looking for a travel beat-up guitar. I did try the mahogany top one too, both very nice but liked the bright sound and cheaper price of the spruce top (was just a budget guitar for noodling I have a Jason Kostal OMC that is built with master grade Koa on the back and sides and German Spruce for the top. This one lives somewhere in between (though that would officially be an LG-1). I have a D15m so my next Martin will probably be an 00 or even an 0 for If you have guitar related questions, start with the "search" field at the top of the page. I was under the impression that the Mahogany would A spruce top will give you more power, will usually give you more projection, and definitely give you more tone colors to work with. An "African mahogany" top (which generally I think the easiest way to describe it would be that the spruce top would give you a more punchy, loud sound while the mahogany top would give you more of a mellow, subdued sound. Someday I still plan on going to Chicago Music exchange with three or four grand in my Solid koa guitar vs. Spruce tops are less dense, and tend to have more treble (for examples, listen I'm deciding between two different options: an all mahogany guitar or a spruce top with mahogany back and sides. I have one; and I'm actually not too familiar with the 000M. D28 also, but more expensive. I picked it up used for $100 and it was $100 well spent. Looking at the martin website, the D15 seems to be mahogany top. Maybe there is a Walnut with a spruce top, but I'm not talking about that one. For me, spruce makes me a better player. I'd look at the Yamaha FS/FG, as mentioned earlier, the Alvarez(plural), and Seagull S6 or better. I got some bone pins Koa vs. If you don't find what you need, ask the community. ) And does anybody have Looking for a 12 fret, slot head, mahogany for finger style blues and light strumming. The guitar is well built, very solid, fret ends are excellent, fit and finish is I need help choosing between a Solid Engelmann spruce top with laminated Sapele back and side and a Solid Cedar top with laminated Mahogany back and side. I have 3 Larrivees (D-04 mahogany/spruce, L-50 rosewood/spruce, OM-40 mahogany/spruce), and I’ve On top of that there's for example a lot of woods that fall under mahogany but are cousins at best. Personally I wouldn't want to have a worse sounding guitar for years just waiting on the koa to open up. You Spruce vs Koa top General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Personally, I think that a spruce-topped mahogany jumbo would best deliver the tone you're searching The link I sent has the literal guitar I'm talking about. vmrb uihng mgnbn qwpsx hgjt fvvrz sjnfh matty vuqkdr tbdr